1. Proceedings
  2. I3M
  3. 2019
  4. EMSS
  5. 10.46354/i3m.2019.emss.045

Modelling and simulation tools for integrating forward and reverse logistics: a literature review

  • a Giulio Paolo Agnusdei  ,
  • b Maria Grazia Gnoni  ,
  • c Fabiana Tornese  
  • a,b,c Department of Innovation Engineering, University of Salento, Lecce, Italy
Cite as
Agnusdei G.P., Elia V., Gnoni M.G., Tornese F. (2019). Modelling and simulation tools for integrating forward and reverse logistics: a literature review. Proceedings of the 31st European Modeling & Simulation Symposium (EMSS 2019), pp. 317-326. DOI: https://doi.org/10.46354/i3m.2019.emss.045.

Abstract

The scientific and technical interest towards sustainability issues is increasing in the industrial sector; thus, closed-loop supply chains are getting more and more diffused. As recycling and remanufacturing strategies are becoming a common practice, the importance of reverse logistics is nowadays increasing. Practitioners need to face with both strategic and operational level decisions related to the coordination of direct and reverse logistic flows. While several reviews are available on reverse logistics and closed-loop supply chains, a summary of scientific literature on integrated forward and reverse logistics is still missing. This paper proposes a review of the literature focused on how to integrate forward and reverse logistics in the industrial sector. The main purpose is to identify advantages and criticalities of current tools highlighted by researchers on this topic, with particular attention to modelling and simulation tools. A critical analysis on the benefits and challenges of the main methods identified is proposed. A discussion about potentialities provided by simulation modelling is also discussed.

References

  1. Afshari, H., Sharafi, M., ElMekkawy, T.Y., Peng, Q., 2016. Multi-objective optimisation of facility location decisions within integrated forward/reverse logistics under uncertainty. Int. J. Bus. Perform. Supply Chain Model. 8, 250.
  2. Afshari, H., Sharifi, M., ElMekkawy, T.Y., Peng, Q., 2014. Facility Location Decisions within Integrated Forward/Reverse Logistics under Uncertainty. Procedia CIRP, Variety Management in Manufacturing 17, 606–610.
  3. Al-Salem, M., Diabat, A., Dalalah, D., Alrefaei, M., 2016. A closed-loop supply chain management problem: Reformulation and piecewise linearization. J. Manuf. Syst. 40, 1–8.
  4. Barker, T.J., Zabinsky, Z.B., 2008. Reverse Logistics Network Design: A Framework for Decision Making, in: Proceedings of the 2008 Industrial Engineering Research Conference. pp. 1290–1295.
  5. Behmanesh, E., Pannek, J., 2018. The Effect of Various Parameters of Solution Methodology on a Flexible Integrated Supply Chain Model. Math. Probl. Eng. 2018, 1–14.
  6. Behmanesh, E., Pannek, J., 2016. A memetic algorithm with extended random path encoding for a closed loop supply chain model with flexible delivery. Logist. Res. 9, 22.
  7. Brailsford, S.C., Eldabi, T., Kunc, M., Mustafee, N., Osorio, A.F., 2019. Hybrid simulation modelling in operational research: A state-of-the-art review. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 278, 721–737.
  8. Cárdenas, I., Beckers, J., Vanelslander, T., 2017. Ecommerce last-mile in Belgium: Developing an external cost delivery index. Res. Transp. Bus. Manag. 24, 123–129.
  9. Chang, T.-S., Liao, Y.-F., 2011. Routing strategies for integrating forward distribution and reverse collection. J. Oper. Res. Soc. 62, 971–981.
  10. Chen, Y., Liu, D., Mao, H., Tian, Y., 2008. Uncertain programming of the distribution/recovery center in forward/reverse hybrid logistics system, in: 2008 IEEE International Conference on Service Operations and Logistics, and Informatics, pp. 3057–3062. Beijing (China).
  11. Chen, Y.-W., Wang, L.-C., Wang, A., Chen, T.-L., 2017. A particle swarm approach for optimizing a multi-stage closed loop supply chain for the solar cell industry. Robot. Comput. Integr. Manuf. 43, 111–123.
  12. Choudhary, A., Sarkar, S., Settur, S., Tiwari, M.K., 2015. A carbon market sensitive optimization model for integrated forward–reverse logistics. Int. J. Prod. Econ. 164, 433–444.
  13. Chung, S.-L., Wee, H.-M., Yang, P.-C., 2008. Optimal policy for a closed-loop supply chain inventory system with remanufacturing. Math. Comput. Model. 48, 867–881.
  14. Cilacı Tombuş, A., Aras, N., Verter, V., 2017. Designing distribution systems with reverse flows. J. Remanufacturing 7, 113–137.
  15. Coenen, J., van der Heijden, R.E.C.M., van Riel, A.C.R., 2018. Understanding approaches to complexity and uncertainty in closed-loop supply chain management: Past findings and future directions. J. Clean. Prod. 201, 1–13.
  16. Das, D., Dutta, P., 2013a. Simulation Study of an Integrated Reverse Logistics in Fuzzy Environment, in: Yang, G.-C., Ao, S.-I., Huang, X., Castillo, O., IAENG Transactions on Engineering Technologies: Special Issue of the International MultiConference of Engineers and Computer Scientists 2012. Springer Netherlands, Dordrecht, 151–165.
  17. Das, D., Dutta, P., 2013b. A system dynamics framework for integrated reverse supply chain with three way recovery and product exchange policy. Comput. Ind. Eng. 66, 720–733.
  18. Das, D., Dutta, P., 2012. A System Dynamics Framework for an Integrated Forward-Reverse Supply Chain with Fuzzy Demand and Fuzzy Collection Rate under Possibility Constraints, in: Proceedings of the International MultiConference of Engineers and Computer Scientists (Hong Kong).
  19. de la Fuente, M.V., Ros, L., Cardós, M., 2008. Integrating Forward and Reverse Supply Chains: Application to a metal-mechanic company. Int. J. Prod. Econ. 111, 782–792.
  20. De Rosa, V., Gebhard, M., Hartmann, E., Wollenweber, J., 2013. Robust sustainable bi-directional logistics network design under uncertainty. Int. J. Prod. Econ. 145, 184–198.
  21. Ding, S., 2010. Logistics Network Design and Optimization Based on Fuzzy Adaptive Differential Evolution Algorithm, in: International Conference on Biomedical Engineering and Computer Science, 1–4. IEEE, (Wuhan, China).
  22. Djikanovic, J., Joksimovic, D., Vujosevic, M., 2015. Application of Variable Neighbourhood Search Method for Vehicle-Routing Problems in an Integrated Forward and Reverse Logistic Chain. Acta Polytech. Hung. 12, 51–70.
  23. Djikanovic, J., Vujosević, M., 2016. A new integrated forward and reverse logistics model: A case study. Int. J. Comput. Intell. Syst. 9, 25–35.
  24. Dondo, R.G., Méndez, C.A., 2016. Operational planning of forward and reverse logistic activities on multi-echelon supply-chain networks. Comput. Chem. Eng. 88, 170–184.
  25. Easwaran, G., Üster, H., 2010. A closed-loop supply chain network design problem with integrated forward and reverse channel decisions. IIE Trans. 42, 779–792.
  26. Elahi, B., Franchetti, M., 2014. A new optimization model for closed-loop supply chain networks, in: 2014 IEEE International Technology Management Conference, 1–9. (Chicago, IL, USA).
  27. Elia, V., Gnoni, M.G., 2015. Designing an effective closed loop system for pallet management. Int. J. Prod. Econ. 170, 730–740.
  28. Elia, V., Gnoni, M.G., Tornese, F., 2019. Designing a sustainable dynamic collection service for WEEE: an economic and environmental analysis through simulation. Waste Manag. Res. 37, 402–411.
  29. Elia, V., Gnoni, M.G., Tornese, F., 2018. Improving logistic efficiency of WEEE collection through dynamic scheduling using simulation modeling. Waste Manag. 72, 78–86.
  30. Elia, V., Gnoni, M.G., Tornese, F., 2016. Measuring circular economy strategies through index methods: A critical analysis. J. Clean. Prod.
  31. Ellen MacArthur Foundation, 2013. Towards the Circular Economy - Economic and business rationale for an accelerated transition.
  32. Faccio, M., Persona, A., Sgarbossa, F., Zanin, G., 2011. Multi-stage supply network design in case of reverse flows: a closed-loop approach. Int. J. Oper. Res. 12, 157.
  33. Fattahi, M., Govindan, K., 2017. Integrated forward/reverse logistics network design under uncertainty with pricing for collection of used products. Ann. Oper. Res. 253, 193–225.
  34. Gajpal, Y., Abad, P.L., 2010. Checking the feasibility of a vehicle route in integrated supply chain transportation model. Int. J. Bus. Perform. Supply Chain Model. 2, 258–281.
  35. Galvão Scheidegger, A.P., Fernandes Pereira, T., Moura de Oliveira, M.L., Banerjee, A., Barra Montevechi, J.A., 2018. An introductory guide for hybrid simulation modelers on the primary simulation methods in industrial engineering identified through a systematic review of the literature. Comput. Ind. Eng. 124, 474–492.
  36. Garg, K., Sanjam, Jain, A., Jha, P.C., 2014. Designing a Closed-Loop Logistic Network in Supply Chain by Reducing its Unfriendly Consequences on Environment, in: Babu, B.V., Nagar, A., Deep, K., Pant, M., Bansal, J.C., Ray, K., Gupta, U., Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Soft Computing for Problem Solving, 1483–1498, December 28-30, 2012. New Delhi (India).
  37. Gnoni, M.G., Mossa, G., Mummolo, G., Tornese, F., Verriello, R., 2017. Circular economy strategies for electric and electronic equipment: a fuzzy cognitive map. Environ. Eng. Manag. J. 16, 1807–1817.
  38. Govindan, K., Agarwal, V., Darbari, J.D., Jha, P.C., 2019. An integrated decision making model for the selection of sustainable forward and reverse logistic providers. Ann. Oper. Res. 273, 607–650.
  39. Govindan, K., Soleimani, H., Kannan, D., 2015. Reverse logistics and closed-loop supply chain: A comprehensive review to explore the future. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 240, 603–626.
  40. Gu, Q.L., Ji, J.H., 2008. An integrated logistics operational model for Remanufacturing/Manufacturing system based on the consumer market. Int. J. Logist. Syst. Manag. 4, 21.
  41. Guide, V.D.R., Van Wassenhove, L.N., 2009. OR FORUM—The Evolution of Closed-Loop Supply Chain Research. Oper. Res. 57, 10–18.
  42. Guo, H., Li, C., Zhang, Y., Zhang, C., Wang, Y., 2018. A Nonlinear Integer Programming Model for Integrated Location, Inventory, and Routing Decisions in a Closed-Loop Supply Chain. Complexity 2018, 1–17.
  43. Habibi, Muh.K.K., Battaïa, O., Cung, V.-D., Dolgui, A., Tiwari, M.K., 2019. Sample average approximation for multi-vehicle collection–disassembly problem under uncertainty. Int. J. Prod. Res. 57, 2409–2428.
  44. Hatefi, S.M., Jolai, F., 2015. Reliable forward-reverse logistics network design under partial and complete facility disruptions. Int. J. Logist. Syst. Manag. 20, 370.
  45. Hatefi, S.M., Jolai, F., 2014. Robust and reliable forward–reverse logistics network design under demand uncertainty and facility disruptions. Appl. Math. Model. 38, 2630–2647.
  46. Hatefi, S.M., Jolai, F., Torabi, S.A., Tavakkoli-Moghaddam, R., 2016. Integrated forward-reverse logistics network design under uncertainty and reliability consideration. Sci. Iran. 23, 721–735.
  47. Hatefi, S.M., Jolai, F., Torabi, S.A., Tavakkoli-Moghaddam, R., 2015. A credibility-constrained programming for reliable forward–reverse logistics network design under uncertainty and facility disruptions. Int. J. Comput. Integr. Manuf. 28, 664–678.
  48. Hatefi, S. M., Jolai, F., Torabi, S.A., Tavakkoli-Moghaddam, R., 2015. Reliable design of an integrated forward-revere logistics network under uncertainty and facility disruptions: A fuzzy possibilistic programing model. KSCE J. Civ. Eng. 19, 1117–1128.
  49. Islam, M.T., Huda, N., 2018. Reverse logistics and closed-loop supply chain of Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE)/E-waste: A comprehensive literature review. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 137, 48–75.
  50. Jaaron, A.A.M., Backhouse, C., 2016. A systems approach for forward and reverse logistics design. Int. J. Logist. Manag.
  51. Jalil, S.A., Hashmi, N., Asim, Z., Javaid, S., 2019. A de-centralized bi-level multi-objective model for integrated production and transportation problems in closed-loop supply chain networks. Int. J. Manag. Sci. Eng. Manag. 14, 206–217.
  52. Jayant, A., Kumar, S., 2012. Simulation Modeling of Integrated Supply Chain Logistics Networks, in: Deep, K., Nagar, A., Pant, M., Bansal, J.C. (Eds.), Proceedings of the International Conference on Soft Computing for Problem Solving, December 20-22, 2011, Advances in Intelligent and Soft Computing. Springer India, 101–111.
  53. Jensen, J.P., Prendeville, S.M., Bocken, N.M.P., Peck, D., 2019. Creating sustainable value through remanufacturing: Three industry cases. J. Clean. Prod. 218, 304–314.
  54. Jinlan, L., Ni, J., 2007. A Hybrid Immune Genetic Algorithm Approach to Optimize the Integrated Forward/Reverse Logistics Network for 3PLs, in: Third International Conference on Natural Computation (ICNC 2007), IEEE, 609–613. Haikou (China).
  55. Kaboudani, Y., Ghodsypour, S.H., Kia, H., Shahmardan, A., 2018. Vehicle routing and scheduling in cross docks with forward and reverse logistics. Oper. Res.
  56. Keyvanshokooh, E., Fattahi, M., Seyed-Hosseini, S.M., Tavakkoli-Moghaddam, R., 2013. A dynamic pricing approach for returned products in integrated forward/reverse logistics network design. Appl. Math. Model. 37, 10182–10202.
  57. Kim, T., Goyal, S.K., Kim, C.-H., 2013. Lot-streaming policy for forward–reverse logistics with recovery capacity investment. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 68, 509–522.
  58. Ko, H.J., Evans, G.W., 2007. A genetic algorithm-based heuristic for the dynamic integrated forward/reverse logistics network for 3PLs. Comput. Oper. Res. 34, 346–366.
  59. Lee, D.-H., Bian, W., Dong, M., 2007a. Multiproduct Distribution Network Design of Third-Party Logistics Providers with Reverse Logistics Operations. Transp. Res. Rec. J. Transp. Res. Board 2008, 26–33.
  60. Lee, D.-H., Bian, W., Dong, M., 2007b. Multiobjective Model and Solution Method for Integrated Forward and Reverse Logistics Network Design for Third-Party Logistics Providers. Transp. Res. Rec. J. Transp. Res. Board 2032, 43–52.
  61. Lee, D.-H., Dong, M., 2008. A heuristic approach to logistics network design for end-of-lease computer products recovery. Transp. Res. Part E Logist. Transp. Rev. 44, 455–474.
  62. Lee, H., Zhang, T., Boile, M., Theofanis, S., Choo, S., 2013. Designing an integrated logistics network in a supply chain system. KSCE J. Civ. Eng. 17, 806–814.
  63. Lee, J.-E., Lee, K.-D., 2012. Integrated forward and reverse logistics model: a case study in distilling and sale company in Korea. Int. J. Innov. Comput. Inf. Control 8, 4483–4495.
  64. Lee, Y.J., Baker, T., Jayaraman, V., 2012. Redesigning an integrated forward–reverse logistics system for a third party service provider: an empirical study. Int. J. Prod. Res. 50, 5615–5634.
  65. Lin, L., Gen, M., Wang, X., 2009. Integrated multistage logistics network design by using hybrid evolutionary algorithm. Comput. Ind. Eng. 56, 854–873.
  66. Lu, T., Zhao, X., 2010. Reverse Logistics Network Design with Consideration of Forward and Reverse Facility Integration, in: 2010 International Conference on E-Business and E-Government. IEEE, 3271–3274. Guangzhou (China).
  67. Mehdizadeh, E., Afrabandpei, F., Mohaselafshar, S., Afshar-Nadjafi, B., 2013. Design of a multi-stage transportation network in a supply chain system: Formulation and efficient solution procedure. Sci. Iran. 20, 2188–2200.
  68. Mitra, S., 2012. Inventory management in a twoechelon closed-loop supply chain with correlated demands and returns. Comput. Ind. Eng. 62, 870–879.
  69. Niknejad, A., Petrovic, D., 2014. Optimisation of integrated reverse logistics networks with different product recovery routes. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 238, 143–154.
  70. Nobari, A., Kheirkhah, A., 2017. Integrated and Dynamic Design of Sustainable Closed-loop Supply Chain Network Considering Pricing. Sci. Iran. 6(25), 410–430.
  71. Orendorff, A., 2019. The plague of Ecommerce return rates and how to maintain profitability. Shopify. URL:https://www.shopify.com/enterprise/ecommerce-returns (accessed 7.3.19).
  72. Pedram, A., Yusoff, N.B., Udoncy, O.E., Mahat, A.B., Pedram, P., Babalola, A., 2017. Integrated forward and reverse supply chain: A tire case study. Waste Manag. 60, 460–470.
  73. Peng, Y., Yao, H., 2007. Integrated Networks of Third Party Logistics Service Providers, in: International Conference on Transportation Engineering 2007, 1530–1535. Chengdu (China).
  74. Pishvaee, M.S., Farahani, R.Z., Dullaert, W., 2010. A memetic algorithm for bi-objective integrated forward/reverse logistics network design. Comput. Oper. Res. 37, 1100–1112.
  75. Pishvaee, M.S., Jolai, F., Razmi, J., 2009. A stochastic optimization model for integrated forward/reverse logistics network design. J. Manuf. Syst. 28, 107–114.
  76. Ponte, B., Naim, M.M., Syntetos, A.A., 2019. The value of regulating returns for enhancing the dynamic behaviour of hybrid manufacturing-remanufacturing systems. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 278, 629–645.
  77. Porkar, S., Mahdavi, I., Maleki Vishkaei, B., Hematian, M., 2018. Green supply chain flow analysis with multi-attribute demand in a multi-period product development environment. Oper. Res.
  78. Radhi, M., Zhang, G., 2019. Optimal cross-channel return policy in dual-channel retailing systems. Int. J. Prod. Econ. 210, 184–198.
  79. Rezaei, S., Kheirkhah, A., 2017. Applying forward and reverse cross-docking in a multi-product integrated supply chain network. Prod. Eng. 11, 495–509.
  80. Roghanian, E., Kamandanipour, K., 2013. A fuzzy random programming for integrated closed-loop logistics network design by using priority-based genetic algorithm. Int. J. Ind. Eng. Comput. 4, 139–154.
  81. Ross, A., Khajehnezhad, M., Otieno, W., Aydas, O., 2017. Integrated location-inventory modelling under forward and reverse product flows in the used merchandise retail sector: A multi-echelon formulation. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 259, 664–676.
  82. Saarijärvi, H., Sutinen, U.-M., Harris, L.C., 2017. Uncovering consumers’ returning behaviour: a study of fashion e-commerce. Int. Rev. Retail Distrib. Consum. Res. 27, 284–299.
  83. Sahyouni, K., Savaskan, R.C., Daskin, M.S., 2007. A Facility Location Model for Bidirectional Flows. Transp. Sci. 41, 484–499.
  84. Shulman, J.D., Coughlan, A.T., Savaskan, R.C., 2009. Optimal Restocking Fees and Information Provision in an Integrated Demand-Supply Model of Product Returns. Manuf. Serv. Oper. Manag. 11, 577–594.
  85. Soleimani, H., Seyyed-Esfahani, M., Shirazi, M.A., 2016. A new multi-criteria scenario-based solution approach for stochastic forward/reverse supply chain network design. Ann. Oper. Res. 242, 399–421.
  86. Tan, Y., Guo, C., 2019. Research on Two-Way Logistics Operation with Uncertain Recycling Quality in Government Multi-Policy Environment. Sustainability 11, 882.
  87. van Loon, P., Delagarde, C., Van Wassenhove, L.N., Mihelič, A., 2019. Leasing or buying white goods: comparing manufacturer profitability versus cost to consumer. Int. J. Prod. Res. 1–15.
  88. Wang, L.-C., Chen, T.-L., Chen, Y.-Y., Chen, Y.-W., Wang, A., 2013. Closed-Loop Sustainable Supply Chain Design Under Uncertainties, in: Azevedo, A. (Ed.), Advances in Sustainable and Competitive Manufacturing Systems. Springer International Publishing, Heidelberg, 799–812.
  89. Wang, M., Di, W.-M., 2010. A location-inventory model for integrated forward/reverse logistics network design, in: 2010 International Conference on Management Science & Engineering 17th Annual Conference Proceedings, IEEE, 299–304, Melbourne (Australia).
  90. Wang, X., Zhao, L., 2009. Network Design of Reverse Logistics Intergrated with Forward Logictics, in: 2009 Asia-Pacific Power and Energy Engineering Conference, IEEE, 1–4, Wuhan (China).
  91. Wang, Y., Lu, T., Zhang, C., 2013. Integrated Logistics Network Design in Hybrid Manufacturing/Remanufacturing System Under Low-Carbon Restriction, in: Zhang, Z., Zhang, R., Zhang, J., LISS 2012. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 111–121.
  92. Wassan, N., Nagy, G., 2014. Vehicle Routing Problem with Deliveries and Pickups: Modelling Issues and Meta-heuristics Solution Approaches. Int. J. Transp. 2, 95–110.
  93. Xie, R.H., Qiu, Z.Q., Zhang, Y.Y., 2007. A New Heuristics for VRP with Simultaneous Delivery and Pick-Up. Presented at the International Conference on Transportation Engineering, Southwest Jiaotong University, Chengdu (China).
  94. Yazdi, A.A., Honarvar, M., 2015. A Two Stage Stochastic Programming Model of the Price Decision Problem in the Dual-channel Closed-loop Supply Chain. Int. J. Eng. 28.
  95. Zhang, T., Chaovalitwongse, W.A., Zhang, Y., 2014. Integrated Ant Colony and Tabu Search approach for time dependent vehicle routing problems with simultaneous pickup and delivery. J. Comb. Optim. 28, 288–309.
  96. Zhou, X., 2015. A Random Multi-objective Model on Integrated Logistics. World J. Model. Simul. 11, 3–15.
  97. Zhou, X., Xu, J., 2009. A class of integrated logistics network model under random fuzzy environment and its application to Chinese beer company. Int. J. Uncertain. Fuzziness Knowl. Based Syst. 17, 807–831.
  98. Zohal, M., Soleimani, H., 2016. Developing an ant colony approach for green closed-loop supply chain network design: a case study in gold industry. J. Clean. Prod. 133, 314–337.